Stolen from everyoung

[dreamcatchings]

Feel free to respond anonymously.


Please rank all of the characters that apply to the games you're in by: love (+2 pts), like (+1 pt), no preference (0 pts), dislike (-1 pts), and hate (-2 pts).


XG:
Paige Guthrie:
Betsy Braddock:
Lucy Evans:
Spiral:

GA:
Illyana Rasputin:

WX:
Paige Guthrie:
Betsy Braddock:


Rules: Be honest and don't cop out. Post anonymously if you're afraid; vent or praise accordingly. I can't fix things until I learn. I'll be fine and I'd like to know which characters need more focus (or less focus) and who I'm just going about wrong. If you list someone as hate or dislike, I'd prefer to know why as otherwise I won't know what to fix. If you don't want to say, that's fine.

Comments

[believeitup.livejournal.com]

XG:
Paige: +2! Jay aside, I have a soft spot for Guthries and she's just spot on. The little thing with her covering up her bra was adorable.
Betsy: +1. I need to read more Betsy threads, I just like that, but I read her thing with JP and I've been keeping up on the NYC threads. She should thread with Hank at some point, I believe.
Lucy: +2 again! I won't say the obvious (I love Lucy *becomes a TV cliche*) but really. She's adorable too. So sweet and lippy and turning things colors and eeee!
Spiral: 0, but only because her I really haven't seen much of anything with. This is likely because I suck.

[magikfanfic.livejournal.com]

Betsy/Hank threadage is so on post-Germany.

[(Anonymous)]

XG because thats it for me

+2- Betsy. A character centric thing because, as you've noted, Jean-Paul's list of people who aren't horrible is: Betsy and maybe floating girl. But she's delightful.

+1- Lucy. She's so delightfully random. She was such a blast to play off and she's very original, as a character.

+1- Paige. She's great and fun, but I've simply had little to do with her and am getting out of touch with my thread-skimming at the moment. But she's awesome.

+1- Spiral. For me, she's hovering somewhere between being an actually-evil power ranger villain, and being this deep raging psychopath. The consistency of her craziness is, from a writing perspective, very well done, but she hasn't really been developed (that we've seen) because the BH is moving so slowly in all its threads.

[cad27.livejournal.com]

Aaaaand that was me, which I really don't mind you knowing and you might need to know who I am for some of that to make sense.

[magikfanfic.livejournal.com]

I feel the same way about Phi. I really do. I like her all crazy but something's gotta give because it can be a really big wall sometimes to be that crazy.

[conductor37.livejournal.com]

Paige - +2 (much love from the older bro, plus you make me like her, dammit)

Betsy - +2 (very nice)

Lucy - +1 (haven't seen enough, but she's fun)

Spiral - 0 (haven't read her yet, sorry)

[laele75.livejournal.com]

XG:
Paige Guthrie: +2 (biased here, because Inner!Jono will kill me if I don't say nice things. ;]) But really, she is more Paige than canon every was. You've redeemed her.
Betsy Braddock: +2 For the dance thread with J-P alone.
Lucy Evans: +1 I loved the scene with Manny and the chex mix. :)
Spiral: +0 Only because I have not read any of her threads. Bad me.

GA:
Illyana Rasputin: +1 I want to see more of her. :)

WX:
Paige Guthrie: +2 Once again, Jono demands I give rave reviews. WX Paige is such a shrew hiding a scared little girl. You make writing Jono off her easy.
Betsy Braddock: +1 Having trouble wrapping my head around her, but I like the concept. :)